The Twilighters Heaven

Discuss Eclipse here!:)

Eclipse was a very nice, settle down kind of story. Edward and Bella's relationship grows and I giggled a bit when Bella tried to seduce Edward. It also deals with Bella's love for Jacob. She realizes that she loves him more than just as a friend, and she tries to decide between Edward and Jacob. Personally, I yelled at the book when she started kissing Jacob OUT OF HER OWN WILL. I was like "Erg! Bella, I hate you right now!" I felt so sorry for Edward when he realized what happened after reading Seth's mind. I was like "AW!!!!" when he didn't blame her and said as long as she was happy, he was happy. He said he would be happy with whatever she chose, and I thought that was sweet. This is absoulutely my favorite book out of the whole series, so share your comments!

-Caroline, site owner

Um, Eclipse was one of my favorites, but I disagree with something you said..."She realizes that she loves him more than just as a friend."

I thought she loved him, but she wasn't in love with him. I mean, I get that she loved him, but don't you think it had to do with the fact that Renesmee was part of her?

HPfan360 at 12:15AM on Feb 21, 2010

Um, Eclipse was one of my favorites, but I disagree with something you said..."She realizes that she loves him more than just as a friend."

I thought she loved him, but she wasn't in love with him. I mean, I get that she loved him, but don't you think it had to do with the fact that Renesmee was part of her?

Yes, I know where you're getting to, but remember at the end of Eclipse when she goes to see Jacob after the newborn fight? She was denying that she loved two people at the same time, but she really did. Don't get me wrong, I love me some Edward, in fact, I like him better than Jacob, but I'm just sticking with Stephenie Meyer's website. And my opinion. As for Renesmee, yes, I realize that Jacob partly only loved her because she was the future mother to Renesmee, but neither of them knew that Nessie was going to be born. But I won't bash on your opinion like other fansites do to each other.